America’s Unique Right to Trial by Jury, Babies and Pets in Injury Cases, BBQ Debate

America’s Unique Right to Trial by Jury, Babies and Pets in Injury Cases, BBQ Debate

July 2026 Newsletter

Rana Law Group Newsletter

In this issue:

  • America’s Unique Right to Trial by Jury!
  • Now You Know: What happens to entities that cannot advocate for themselves like unborn babies or pets in injury cases?
  • Just for Fun: Happy 4th of July – BBQ Debate

America’s Unique Right to Trial by Jury

This past weekend, we celebrated a remarkable moment in our nation’s history: America’s 250th anniversary when a group of ordinary citizens embraced an extraordinary idea. They believed that every person matters, that power must answer to the people and that justice should belong to everyone, not just the privileged, the wealthy, or the powerful.  One of the most important rights we have as Americans is the right to a jury trial.  While a few other countries allow trial by jury in criminal cases, America’s 7th Amendment guarantees them for civil disputes as well.  According to most estimates, America accounts for 80-90% of the world’s jury trials.

Founding Father and second U.S. President John Adams described representative government and trial by jury as “the heart and lungs of liberty.”  Without them, he warned, we would have no real protection against being abused by those with greater power.  That may sound dramatic but it is just as true today as it was then.  It allows ordinary citizens to participate directly in self-government.  It gives people from the community the power to decide what is fair, what is just, and what accountability requires.  It reminds every person, every corporation and every institution that no one is above the law.

As we celebrate 250 years of America, we should remember that our freedoms are not abstract ideas.  They are protected in real places by real people through real institutions.  One of those places is the courtroom. One of those institutions is the jury.  And one of those freedoms is the right of ordinary citizens to decide justice for themselves.  Happy birthday America!

Now You Know: What happens to entities that cannot advocate for themselves like unborn babies or pets in injury cases?

Occasionally, we handle cases where the injury involves someone other than the person sitting in the driver’s seat or walking into our office.  Sometimes a pregnant client is injured in a crash or a beloved pet is hurt because of someone else’s carelessness.  So what does Missouri law allow in those situations?

Let’s start with pregnancy.  If you are injured in a crash or fall while pregnant, the first priority is medical care. We strongly recommend that you contact your OB/GYN or go to the hospital and follow whatever testing or monitoring your doctor recommends.  Even if you feel okay, it is important to make sure both mother and baby are healthy.  It is also important to document what happened, what symptoms you experienced, and what medical providers did to evaluate the pregnancy.

Thankfully, in many cases, the baby is completely healthy.  In that situation, the mother may still have her own injury claim for the crash, including the physical injuries, medical bills, lost wages, and the fear and stress that come with being hurt while pregnant.

If there is a documented injury to the baby, the claim becomes more serious and more complicated.  Medical records, fetal monitoring, ultrasounds, specialist opinions, and causation evidence become very important.  The question is not just whether a crash happened but whether the crash caused injury to the pregnancy or to the child.  In the tragic event that the baby is lost, Missouri law may allow a wrongful death claim.  Missouri recognizes that unborn children have protectable interests in life, health, and well-being and Missouri courts have allowed wrongful death claims involving unborn children following an injury to the mother.  These are extremely sensitive cases and they need to be evaluated carefully with both medical and legal evidence.

What if a pet is injured?  We covered keeping pets safe while traveling more extensively in our September 2023 newsletter.  From an injury case standpoint, Missouri generally treats animals as personal property (legally referred to as chattel).  That does not match how most of us feel about our pets.  To most families, a dog or cat is not “property” in any meaningful emotional sense; rather, they are part of the family.

Unfortunately, owner recourse is limited to economic damages. That may include the fair market value of the pet, the cost to replace a similar animal, and reasonable veterinary bills or related expenses.  What Missouri law generally does not allow is a separate pain and suffering claim for the owner based solely on the emotional loss of the pet.  That can feel unfair, especially when the loss is very real but it is important to understand the limits of the law before deciding how to pursue the claim.  The practical advice is the same in both situations: document everything, get medical/veterinary care, save bills, records, photographs, discharge instructions and any communication with the insurance company.

When an injury involves a pregnancy or a family pet, the legal issues can be more complicated than they first appear.  The best first step is to make sure everyone is safe, get the proper care and then talk with an attorney about what the law allows.

Just for fun: Happy 4th of July – Our BBQ Debate – Main vs. Sides
We hope everyone had a wonderful 4th of July!  As usual, Tarun’s main focus with any holiday is the food.  He had a great spread (pictured below), however, this brought up a debate around the office.  When attending a BBQ, do you look forward to the meat or the sides?  (Note: we may have round two of this argument for Thanksgiving!)

Tarun – Meat/Main – “Wait, what about dessert?  Well, if that’s not an option, then definitely the meat/main!”
Sarah – Sides (grilled veggies)
Brittany – SIDES!!!! (baked beans and deviled eggs please!)
Cheryl (Surprise!  We will introduce our newest colleague in August) – Meat/Main


…..according to Tarun, the key lime pie ‘disappeared’ before any pictures could be taken!

Case Referrals  

From time to time, clients call and ask which type of cases we handle.  Our practice is built on referrals from satisfied clients.  We know that if we work hard and do a good job for our clients, they will tell their friends about us.  The best compliment from a former client is that client entrusting us with the potential case of their friend or family.  Our office specializes in the following cases:

  1. Personal Injury (auto collisions, trucking, motorcycle, premise liability, dog bites, daycare)
  2. Work Injuries
  3. Traffic tickets and DUI/DWI

If you know someone that meets these criteria, please have them call our office.  If someone does not quite fit the above criteria, please still have the prospective referral give us a call as we can usually help the person find the right attorney via a referral.

Share the Love – Reviews

Thank you very much to everyone who already left a review, we appreciate it!  If you have not left one and have some kind words, we would appreciate the time.
  1. For Google: simply click on the link.
  2. For Facebook: please “Like” and “Follow” the page and then click on “Reviews” on the left-hand side
  3. For Avvo: click on “reviews” and then “Review Tarun Rana”

 

 


No Comments

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.