Condo Collapse Preventable, Hospital Pricing & 4th of July

Condo Collapse Preventable, Hospital Pricing & 4th of July

Welcome to the Newsletter

Rana Law Group Newsletter

In this issue:

  • Condo Collapse – Preventable?
  • Hospital Pricing Update
  • 4th of July Festivities

Condo Collapse – Preventable?

The condo collapse in Surfside, Florida is a terrible tragedy and our condolences go out to those impacted by the event.  As we get more news, one of the pieces uncovered is about a 2018 engineering report on the building.  The report indicates there was major structural damage to a concrete slab and waterproofing failed because it was improperly laid.  It is undetermined whether this was the root cause for the failure, however, it raises the question many people will be asking in the aftermath – was this truly an “accident” or was this preventable?  Unfortunately, an update regarding the situation indicates this condo was about to undergo repairs for the structural issues found in 2018.  As a result of the collapse, the mayor of Miami-Dade County announced a 30-day audit of all buildings 40 years and older.

Lawsuits seeking answers and to assess negligence in the condo collapse were already filed.  For those who lost loved ones, it goes without saying that no amount of money will make the loss acceptable.  I suspect many are not filing these lawsuits for money.  At this juncture, it is more about one of the main purposes of tort law, which is to deter negligent behavior.  This was also recently seen in the trial of Derek Chauvin.  One of the purposes of criminal law is to deter behavior we deem unacceptable by using punishment.  In the case of Chauvin, a jury of his peers listened to the evidence, determined he was guilty of some of the charges brought against him and the judge determined it was appropriate to sentence him to 22.5 years as punishment.  The purpose of holding someone accountable is to deter other people who may be faced with the same situation from making bad decisions.  Ideally, the threat or fear of similar punishment will prevent them from committing the same actions.

With the case of the condo collapse in Surfside, tort law functions in the same basic way.  By having a heavy financial disincentive for cutting corners, entities such as the condo owners will be less likely to ignore information which may endanger others.  Remember, the civil justice system only allows for money damages.  We cannot throw the owners of the condo in jail (although a separate, criminal action could be brought if the government believes there is enough evidence to meet their burden of proof), so the family members of those injured or killed in the collapse are left with seeking money damages.  Some of these people may seek other, non-traditional settlement terms.  For instance, they could require the defendants (the responsible parties) to make changes, such as a timelier fix when future issues are discovered.  This would be part of a settlement and not something a court  orders as part of the civil trial.  These types of changes brought on by tragic events have precedent, such as cases against big tobacco and car manufacturers which lead to safer products and warnings.

This was a terrible event that is still on-going, with many families not knowing what happened to their loved ones.  We hope all those impacted in Surfside are able to gain some measure of closure in the coming days.

Hospital Pricing Update

In our January Newsletter, we discussed the government’s attempt to bring transparency to hospital pricing.  According to the new rule, hospitals must provide pricing to consumers via an accessible link on their website.  Several area health systems already posted costs for procedures in an attempt to comply with the hospital price transparency.

For instance, BJCMercy and SSM created online portals to compare pricing for procedures.  Unfortunately, the data can be difficult to understand and you need to know the exact procedure name or ICD code to obtain an accurate estimate.  Even then, there are extensive disclaimers to the hospital pricing listed claiming they are subject to adjustments, discounts, ancillary procedures or supplies and medication.

In the charts below, I compared a common diagnostic procedure as well as a back pain management procedure between healthcare systems and hospitals.  Sometimes, there were substantial differences between hospitals within the same system or, in the case of the pain injection, no pricing data available yet.  This is a good start at increasing transparency in hospital billing and giving power to the consumers.  In most situations, however, people will be at a hospital because of an emergency and price will not be a consideration.  If it is not an emergency, it may be worthwhile to research the cost and then see how health insurance factors into the price for which you may be responsible.  It will be interesting to see how this information will be used in the future.  Access to the data is a great first step to eliminating some of the surprise medical billing associated with obtaining healthcare.

4th of July Festivities

Hopefully many of you were able to enjoy the long holiday weekend with friends, family and some fireworks. We had a typical summer dinner of pork steaks, corn, salad and peach cobbler. As an injury lawyer, I tend to be a buzzkill with engaging in what I now deem as dangerous activities like setting off fireworks but we still had fun watching the town sponsored show from a safe distance. My favorite picture from the weekend was geese swimming against the sunset.

Share the Love

Thank you very much to everyone who already left a review, we appreciate it!  If you have not left one and have some kind words, I would appreciate the time.
  1. For Google: simply click on the link.
  2. For Facebook: please “Like” and “Follow” the page and then click on “Reviews” on the left-hand side
  3. For Avvo: click on “reviews” and then “Review Tarun Rana”
No Comments

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.